We document a contribution from a health worker from Germany, about the current situation of restructuring and struggles. Parts of the text were presented at an international health workers’ meeting in Vienna. We previously interviewed the colleague about his wider experience with the nurses’ movement from the late 1980s onwards, which can be read here.
In terms of further background you can also read these interviews on the historic 2021 strike in Berlin. If you are tired of reading, you could watch this documentary about the strike of outsourced hospital workers, mentioned in the article below.
General description
In Germany, the majority of total healthcare costs are covered by statutory health insurance (GKV) (54 per cent of total costs in 2024). These contributions are currently split 50/50 between workers and employers. From a class perspective, this is a formal division that merely masks the fact that, overall, these are deductions from the surplus value / profits created by workers. At the same time, this is a root cause of the disputes between different employer factions and within the state. Health insurance contributions have been rising for years: part of this money ends up in the pockets of those employers who make profits in this sector, whilst for others it represents costs (including those for the reproduction of the labour force and ‘social peace’) that they wish to reduce.
In addition to the payments from the health insurances, the state contributes around 10 per cent from the budget to cover health service related expenditures, private households contribute currently 12 per cent, long-term care insurance 12 per cent and private insurers 8 per cent. Expenditure on statutory health insurance, measured as a proportion of GDP, remained stable for a long time between 6.5 per cent in 1994 and just under 7 per cent in 2018. It has since risen to almost 8 per cent. Similarly, total healthcare expenditure as a proportion of GDP remained stable for a long time at around 10 per cent – but rose to 13.1 per cent in 2020 (rising expenditure due to the coronavirus pandemic coupled with a fall in GDP). In absolute terms, costs have roughly doubled between 2008 and the present day. The debate centres on the increased health insurance contributions.
Structures
In the outpatient sector, GPs and specialists operate as small business owners; hospitals’ running costs are funded by the statutory health insurance scheme; investment costs should be borne by the federal states, but this sector has been underfunded for decades. The number of hospitals has been declining for years; at the same time, almost 40 per cent of hospitals are now privately run, even though most beds are still located in non-private hospitals.
Hospitals have a second tier of specialists. On the one hand, this ‘dual specialist system’ incurs high costs; at the same time, it is becoming increasingly difficult to secure appointments with specialists ‘outside’ hospitals, whilst hospital A&E departments are becoming increasingly overburdened. The strict separation between hospitals and the outpatient sector in Germany is to be bridged by MVZs (medical care centres) and ‘cross-sector care centres’. This is providing a further opening for the private sector (the left-wing polyclinic initiatives organised within the Poliklinik Syndikat are attempting to join the newly planned structure of the PVZ / primary care centres…)
The sector of long-term and elderly care, comprising outpatient care services and care homes, is divided between private companies and institutions organised by the churches. In the case of care homes, the ratio of private to church-run facilities is approximately 50:50; when it comes to outpatient care services, 70 per cent are operated by private companies, with the remainder run by the churches. However, the churches organise the large, tightly run care institutions, whilst private providers often serve niche markets.
The sector as a whole is growing enormously. In 2024, approximately 1.3 million care workers were employed in outpatient care services and care homes, with part-time workers accounting for over 60 per cent of the workforce. Over the last 15 years, this figure has risen by 50 per cent, whilst the number of people receiving care services has increased by 80 per cent. Around 25 per cent of staff work in these settings without having completed formal training or have entered the sector via a ‘career change’. Hospitals employ around 550,000 care workers, with part-time staff accounting for just under 50 per cent. Wages have risen at an above-average rate over the last 10 years. At a university hospital in Freiburg, the gross salary of a ‘standard nurse’, excluding allowances, ranges between 3,600 and 4,600 euros, depending on professional experience. This is no longer considered an above-average salary.
In around 25 of the approximately 1,800 hospitals, there is a collective agreement on workload reduction / better staff patient ratios, or there have been strike mobilisations there beyond the usual collective bargaining rounds. By rough calculation, this means that potentially 45,000 of the 550,000 nursing staff in hospitals were involved in these mobilisations. That is less than 3 per cent of the total 1.8 million care workers. On the one hand, this underlines the leverage that strike action by care workers in large hospitals can exert; at the same time, however, it highlights the limitations of such action, or rather the trade union’s skilful ‘allocation of resources’. Even though the mobilisations – criticised as ‘lighthouse campaigns’ – remained limited in terms of geographical scope and numbers, they created a ripple effect: many care homes, including those providing care for the elderly, were forced to follow suit on pay and working conditions – even without being bound by collective agreements – in order to retain their staff.
Current ‘reforms’
In general, ‘investment in the workforce’ is to be scaled back. Alongside reducing the costs of sustaining the working class, the healthcare sector is to be expanded whilst simultaneously being privatised. As long as all capitalists are faced with rising labour costs alongside rising healthcare costs, they are not necessarily in favour of a handful of companies – which make their money specifically in this sector – reaping high profits.
In Germany, the government is currently pushing ahead with ‘reforms’ that many compare to the ‘Agenda 2010’ of the Red-Green coalition in the 2000s. [1] In June 2025, the NATO member states agreed to increase military expenditure and spending on military infrastructure to a total of five per cent of GDP – the so-called ‘NATO quota’. In Germany, this corresponds to around 50 per cent of the federal budget. Even though it is still unclear exactly what will be included in this quota – and although it is to be achieved by 2035 at the latest – this represents a significant increase in military spending. At the same time, cuts must be made to the welfare state: a return to the so-called strict ‘revenue-oriented spending policy’ is intended to put the German economy back on the path to growth: hospital reform, long-term care insurance, healthcare reform, pension insurance, a new basic income scheme; at European level, the Common European Asylum System (CEAS) is tightening migration policy.
In the case of long-term care insurance, costs are to be cut by restricting benefits and the number of recipients (both of which had been expanded in 2017) and by reducing subsidies for stays in care homes (which, under the German system, shifts the costs onto local authorities). Equally disgraceful is the planned suspension of the Act on Compliance with Collective Agreements – that is, the relatively new measure that ties wages in this sector to local collective agreements.
The so-called GKV Contribution Stabilisation Act, passed in July 2026, combines traditional ‘cost-cutting measures’ with attacks on workers in these sectors. [2]
Hospital reform
As early as January 2004, hospital funding was switched to a flat-rate per-case payment system [3]: smaller hospitals were expected to close and/or cut further beds, whilst large hospitals are under pressure to rationalise, as the change in hospital funding serves as a means of increasing productivity and further intensifying the workload. At the same time, the privatisation and expansion of the healthcare sector in the hospital environment are intended to facilitate the exploitation of additional cheap, precarious labour.
It took over ten years for major protests to emerge against this trend. In 2019, nursing care was removed from the flat-rate payment system – hospitals didn’t have to pay nurses wages out of the fixed amount for the particular treatment, but were ‘reimbursed’ for the actual hours worked. Since then, the costs of nursing care (‘at the bedside’) in hospitals – including rising wages and increased staffing levels – have had to be covered by health insurance funds. It was ‘with the onset of the coronavirus pandemic’, at the very latest, that the situation in hospitals and the system of flat-rate payments came under widespread public discussion and criticism.
In December 2022, the then SPD minister of health presented a draft on ‘de-economisation in the healthcare sector’, which quickly became a tool for reducing ‘identified overcapacities’. In order to ‘finance the social security systems in the long term’, healthcare expenditure must not ‘decouple’ significantly from GDP. This ‘decoupling’ has been observable for more than ten years and could have “extremely serious consequences for the stability of the social security systems’ for future generations”. (from the draft at the time)
At the same time, the scramble for the ever-increasing cash flows within the system is intensifying. For a long time, a large proportion of this money functioned as redistributed surplus value; now it is to become, if not capital, then at least profit.
In the EU, there were an average of 540 hospital beds per 100,000 inhabitants in 2018 (Italy 318; Sweden 213), whilst in Germany the figure was 800. No simple conclusions can be drawn from these figures (different demographic conditions, different geographical circumstances, social and healthcare systems that have developed historically and also differ in quality). The reformers merely use them as a pretext to cut costs.
This was already the intention behind the per-case flat-rate payments – the ‘market’ was supposed to regulate what is politically difficult to enforce. The result was simultaneous under-provision, over-provision and misallocation of care, as well as a staff shortage.
Hospitals are now to be divided into three so-called levels of care, ranging from regional care up to maximum-care hospitals and university hospitals.
Each level of care is then to be assigned so-called ‘service groups’ (= who is authorised to carry out which type of medical treatment?) and officials define standard requirements which each level should meet. In this way, ‘quality’ becomes the second lever: everyone agrees that patients should be treated where the facilities are capable of doing so. Yet existing partnerships between smaller and larger hospitals are now being undermined; the ‘reform’ aims to force hospitals to compete for or trade particular service groups, thereby bringing about a process of concentration of services and closures.
And Diagnostic Related Groups (DRGs) will continue to account for 60 per cent (40 per cent in certain areas) of health treatments. The so-called ‘de-economised’ (‘de-commodified’) flat-rate payments form a budget that continues to allow for profits and losses. Level 1i facilities are being linked to privately run GPs; this creates a new economic sector for privatisation and private equity funds.
Staff costs in nursing care were identified as the main driver of hospital costs. In 2020, the costs for nursing staff were switched from the controversial flat-rate payment system to the so-called ‘nursing budget’. Since then, the costs of nursing staff have been reimbursed by health insurance funds. This budget has grown significantly every year since then. For this reason, the healthcare reform aims to cap this ‘nursing budget’ by linking it more strictly to the basic wage rate minus one per cent. Furthermore, only 50 per cent of future pay rises are now to be reimbursed by health insurance funds. Taken together, all these measures will drive a large proportion of hospitals into insolvency:
“(…) As soon as the measures come into force, the expected proportion of hospitals reporting an annual loss will rise from 29 per cent in 2026 to 67 per cent in 2027. By the end of the decade, however, this proportion will rise to 81 per cent. We anticipate that by 2030, 49 per cent of hospitals will be at high risk of insolvency …” (according to one of the architects of the hospital reform).
The staffing frameworks for nursing care – which have been developed over many years in committees involving ver.di and all nursing representatives – are effectively to be abolished and replaced by a ‘general standard’: this will allow hospital management to pass on the cost-cutting pressures imposed from above.
The Charité in Berlin has already terminated the ‘Entlastung’ collective agreement (‘relief’ agreement, which determined particular staff – patient ratios, with compensation if you work on a particular amount of understaffed shifts), citing a lack of funds. As the nursing budget has been cut but not yet abolished, the pressure will initially be felt most acutely by other professional groups within the hospitals – a scenario that the reform planners are already predicting: “Staff cuts will therefore take place in the other service areas. There, at least 10 per cent of posts must be cut by 2030 to offset the shortfall in revenue and ensure the financial sustainability of the hospitals.’ Furthermore, the aim is to finally put an end to the ‘employee’s market’ in the care sector and to ‘restore productivity’ (currently, fewer patients are being cared for by more nursing staff than was the case five years ago).
Those who can are seeking positions in the few, but large, hospitals with a collective agreement designed to ease the workload.
The cycle of industrial action in hospitals, which has stalled in 2015 for the time being, began with a difficult legacy: in the preceding years, many hospitals had outsourced large sections of its workforce – the so-called ‘service departments’ – without encountering much resistance. At the same time, the doctors waged a fairly successful ‘independent’ collective bargaining dispute through the Marburger Bund for the first time. These divisions between ‘service staff’ and ‘professionals’ have not been bridged again to this day.
In the recent past, there have been no broad-based, offensive struggles. The struggles for collective agreements to reduce workloads have come to an end for the time being – or rather, these agreements must now be defended! The struggles at the Vivantes subsidiaries and at the Charité over reintegration into the TVÖD [collective agreement for the public sector] or the in-house collective agreement were important – yet they highlight the divisions that came to light during recent strike mobilisations. Similar struggles are taking place in many smaller hospitals, but they usually go unnoticed, mainly because they are isolated ‘struggles from one hospital to the next’.
During the strike at the university hospital Freiburg in the summer of 2026 over the in-house collective agreement for the four university hospitals in Baden-Württemberg, the management cited the need for cost-cutting measures resulting from the reforms. The ver.di campaign followed the usual pattern of collective bargaining disputes, and was even brought to an end – ahead of the upcoming votes on the controversial healthcare reform in the Bundestag and Bundesrat – with the adoption of the TVÖD agreement.
A link to the other hospitals would have to be established by other groups; what is needed is an initiative to forge genuine connections with other sectors and between different institutions. So far, these links have only been established in speeches at demonstrations.
However, this is currently a difficult undertaking, as there are hardly any local structures in place for this purpose
Migration in the healthcare sector
In outpatient care and long-term care, the proportion of migrant workers is over 50 per cent. In my outpatient care service, I have the impression that it stands at 70 to 80 per cent. In training courses, often only a quarter to a fifth of participants are so-called ‘locals’. In hospitals, a large proportion of the increase in nursing staff in recent years has come from many different countries. Reports from the Charité in Berlin suggest that of the approximately 1,000 additional nursing staff who joined following the introduction of the collective agreement (TV-E) – which has since been terminated – at least 50 per cent are colleagues with a migrant background. Due to the whole array of legal and bureaucratic requirements (e.g. the recognition of their qualifications), it often takes several years for them to feel that they have settled in; at the same time, because of their (family) circumstances, they often find themselves in even more individualised living situations than their German colleagues. Some of them, however, are now taking part in specific trade union mobilisations.
The much-discussed militarisation has so far been scarcely an issue in the workplaces. A few left-wing (ver.di) activists are attempting to tackle the issue together with what remains of the hospital workers’ movement – so far without much success. A leaf-letting campaign as part of the mobilisations against compulsory military service met with mixed reactions: often approval, but just as often references to the ‘necessity of defence’. The official / higher-level trade union structures occasionally issue statements against militarisation – but these are not backed up by concrete measures.
Hospital medicine is ‘reactive medicine’. Dealing with health and illness, early detection and early treatment take place at a local (non-hospital) level – as the pandemic has recently shown. In this strictly defined sense, the healthcare system has long since been ‘abolished’. Fewer hospitals – within the framework of an adequate care system – make sense: what could now happen, however, and what is intended by the announced ‘reforms’, are ‘cold-blooded hospital closures’, whilst at the same time the shift towards outpatient care via an expanded private sector is to be driven forward. If we add the long-established findings of medical sociology on health and illness, or the unequal access to healthcare in unequal societies, the outlook becomes relatively clear…
Beyond all ideological debates, critics and proponents of ‘market-oriented’ approaches actually agree on the changes to the basic structure of hospital planning: The aim is to find the right mix of local outpatient care and hospitals. Proponents of the market want to combine ‘community nurses’ with private GPs and private medical centres, alongside fewer large hospitals – which are, moreover, increasingly being privatised. ‘Left-wingers’ who draw on the socialist past want a (state-run?) planned and funded mix of community-based care, workplace health promotion, polyclinics and hospitals.
However, such discussions will only become truly convincing when they are taken up by movements of care staff or workers in this sector.
How might things progress?
- We are dealing with a workforce which, historically speaking, achieved relative success relatively quickly, and in the process developed a ‘trade union consciousness’. A workforce which now, however, faces the threat that much of this could be lost just as quickly.
- The power of these workers is the result of the struggles of the (‘industrial’) working class (in England, this remains more visible to this day, even though the NHS is also ‘defended’ by other workers). Is there a possibility that these healthcare workers, who are now coming under pressure following relatively successful mobilisations, could become a catalyst, a driving force for more general struggles against the current austerity ‘reforms’!? Similar, for example, to what happened in France in 1995, or to the prevention of cuts to sick pay in Germany in the mid-1990s!?
- On the ‘positive side’ are the strikes and experiences of mobilisation over the last ten years. Workers in the ‘outsourced’ sectors have, in some cases, waged tough strikes. Unlike 10 or 15 years ago, many colleagues in hospitals have already gone on strike at some point.
In the care sector, pay is often good, and working conditions have improved in many hospitals and care homes
Surely that’s worth defending!?
- To do this, we would need to discuss the limitations of previous mobilisations. The ‘care budget’ – whether seen as a success or rather as the outcome of the last cycle of struggle – has a contradictory effect in terms of class politics: it is a success for the hospital movement – yet at the same time, it has cemented the divisions that have existed since the start of the cycle, e.g. the division between nurses and other hospital staff. The longer it is since the specific struggles took place, and the longer no new ones are waged, the more it solidifies into ‘institutionalised class struggle’, a ‘collective bargaining success’ in the negative sense, exclusively for nursing staff. Added to this is the form that the strikes and mobilisations of recent years have often taken: the trade union’s campaigns, its organising efforts and its strike strategies (involving complex emergency service agreements) have managed to mobilise a relatively large number of colleagues in the hospitals concerned, despite the individualisation of the past decades.
Currently, the management of the Charité is refusing to implement similar emergency service regulations, and has also successfully challenged these restrictions in court. This has so far significantly limited the effectiveness of the strikes and mobilisations. This highlights the need to discuss the limitations of the cycle that has now come to an end, and to explore new forms of strike action and/or mobilisation. A group of young doctors at Charité is currently trying to rally their colleagues to support or participate in the strike mobilizations in support of the collective bargaining agreement on workload reduction…
Footnotes
[1]
On Agenda 2010
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agenda_2010
https://libcom.org/article/protests-against-welfare-reform-germany-2004
[2]
A description and analysis of the measures can be found at https://www.krankenhaus-statt-fabrik.de/wp-content/uploads/2026/08/KsF_Bewertung_GKV-BStabG.pdf
[3]
Hospitals are paid a fixed amount for a certain treatment. If they can provide the treatment with less (labour) cost, they can cash in the profit. If they need to spend more, they pay it out of their own pocket. This led to many hospitals only focussing on particular treatments, which promised bigger profits, e.g. cardiac surgery – while neglecting others, e.g. mental health or midwifery treatments.




